I noticed a growing trend in my feeds today - a lot of chatter about linking social profiles and a general loathing of the practice.
Scott Stratten (@unmarketing on Twitter) used a bit of humor to illustrate his disdain. No surprise there; Scott is the king of tongue-in-cheek humor. But, he’s also a pretty smart guy. I recommend following him if you don’t already.

For those new to the game, linking your social profiles refers to the process of essentially syndicating your posts from one network to another network. For example, if you link Facebook and Twitter, your Facebook status updates will be posted as tweets to your Twitter account. Conversely, if you send a Twitter update, that content will be posted to your Facebook profile. You can do the same with Twitter and LinkedIn. You get the idea.
While there are certainly times where is makes sense to post content to multiple social networks, it is important to understand that each network has a unique audience and purpose. Therefore, a “one-size-fits-all” approach to content doesn’t make sense.
Think about it: chances are, your professional connections (LinkedIn) aren’t going to see much value in your tweet that states, “Grabbing a burger for lunch.” Similarly, your Facebook friends probably aren’t going to care about the link you shared to a comprehensive white paper illustrating the growing trend of Six Sigma certifications in companies with fewer than 150 employees (I made that up, by the way).
Different networks. Different people. Different relationships. Different expectations.
Besides, with tools like HootSuite (aff.), TweetDeck, Seesmic and others that allow you to post to one or more social profiles from a single interface, there isn’t a need to use “traditional profile linking.” These tools allow you to control what content gets distributed to which social profile(s). Filtering your posts shows the people who care enough to connect with you that you care enough about them to not just spew things into their stream “because you can.”
What do you think? Is linking social profiles a good idea? Bad idea? Do you do it? Why or why not? What tips do you have?
About a month or so ago, through a stream of tweets and blog posts surrounding the